Shadow Complex is a recent XBLA (Xbox Live Arcade) game. It is loosely based on the universe found in Orson Scott Card’s Empire novels.
The controversy is about whether or not we should boycott the game because Orson Scott Card is a proponent of traditional marriage. Or to put it as it is in the original post:
Now why should we boycott it? Card is a notorious homophobe
Here is the full neogaf thread, and here is a decent article discussing it.
Please note that the game has nothing to do with gay marriage, and Orson Scott Card had very little to do with the game.
As a creator this controversy has stirred up some odd feelings.
Before I go on, let me clarify some of my personal views.
First, I’m a big fan of the works of Orson Scott Card. He is is a very talented author. Please keep in mind that I don’t go to him for religious or political news or opinion. I don’t know him personally, nor am I likely to in the future. His personal views are his own and they do not diminish the respect I have towards him as a creator.
Second, I am not against gay marriage. I also don’t believe that a priest, or other religious member, should be forced to perform a gay marriage if it’s against their views.
In one aspect, I’m really scared by this type of thing.
I create works to be viewed and discussed as they are, not as I am. It’s one thing for people to avoid the work because they don’t agree with the subject matter or the way I handle it, but another thing altogether because of me or my personal views. To not even give the work a chance because of something that I think or say.
On the other hand, I firmly believe a person’s money and viewpoint are their own. If they choose not to sponsor a creator because of that person’s views than that is for them to decide.
I do view that this type of thought and behavior can be dangerous for the industry. Most game businesses will not look at why people refused to buy a game. In the end, they will just look at whether or not that game failed in the market, and then decide if they should make a similar game. A boycott, especially one not based on what they game is or what it is about, is only going to hurt the industry as a whole.
For this situation in specific, I would like people to keep in mind the many people who have slaved away to bring this game to market. What of their views, their families, their homes? What if these people don’t agree with Orson Scott Card on this matter that is unrelated to the actual game? You may be putting them out of a job because of someone else’s belief; especially a belief that has no bearing on the product in question.
For works such as novels, where primarily one person is directly effected by sales, boycotting can be an effective tool to express your take on the matter. For something like a game though, which is usually not created by a sole individual anymore, this seems like there would be an excessive amount of collateral damage.
I will leave you with a thought provoking response by xbhaskarx, a poster at neogaf:
Do you not buy products like electronics that are made using raw materials extracted from African countries where millions of people are killed, like the Democratic Republic of Congo? Do you not buy products like [half the stuff you own] that benefit dictatorial regimes that utilize labor camps and engage in organ harvesting like the People’s Republic of China? Do you not drive a car because such a large percentage of our oil comes from countries that ban homosexuality altogether like Saudi Arabia?